When you send an email, your message doesn't just rely on its content or design to make it to the recipient's inbox. A significant factor working behind the scenes is your IP address—the digital identifier that can significantly impact your email deliverability.

Quick Answer: A shared IP address is used by multiple senders and is less expensive, while a dedicated IP address is exclusive to one sender and provides complete reputation control. Choose shared IPs for under 50K emails monthly, dedicated IPs for 100K+ emails.

What are IP Addresses in Email Marketing? 

Think of your IP address as the return address on a letter. Email providers like Gmail and Outlook use this digital identifier to determine whether your message should be trusted or sent to the spam folder.

Even a perfectly written email can end up flagged as spam or rejected outright if the IP reputation is poor.

This is why businesses need to pay attention to the type of IP address they use for sending emails. There are two primary options: shared IP addresses and dedicated IP addresses. Multiple senders share a shared IP address, whereas only one sender uses a dedicated IP address.

Whether you’re sticking with shared IPs or looking to get a dedicated IP address, each comes with its own benefits, drawbacks, and specific use cases. Choosing the right one is key to protecting your email reputation and ensuring your messages reach their intended audience.

So, which IP is best for your email campaigns: Dedicated vs. Shared IP address?

Let’s take a closer look to understand better.

Shared IP Address vs Dedicated IP Address

What is a Shared IP Address?

A shared IP address is an IP address that multiple users share to send their emails. Most email providers likely rely on a shared IP.

Here’s how it works: your emails, along with those from other businesses, are sent through the same IP address managed by the email service provider. 

This means the IP’s reputation is collectively influenced by all the senders using it. If most users follow good practices—such as sending high-quality emails to verified contacts—the shared IP can maintain a solid sender reputation.

However, there’s a potential downside. If other users engage in spammy practices, such as sending emails to unverified lists, the reputation of the IP can take a hit. This can negatively affect your email deliverability, even if you’ve done everything right.

Examples of when shared IPs are commonly used:

• Small businesses or startups sending low volumes of email.
• Companies are testing email campaigns before committing to a dedicated IP.
• Organizations looking for a cost-effective solution, as shared IPs are included in most email service provider plans.

What Is a Dedicated IP Address?

A dedicated IP address is assigned to a single sender, meaning your emails are the only ones sent from that IP. This setup gives you complete control over your sending reputation and ensures that no other sender’s actions can impact your email deliverability.

In email campaigns, a dedicated IP offers exclusivity. It’s particularly valuable for businesses that send high volumes of outreach emails or need consistent deliverability for critical communications. 

For example, e-commerce platforms that send transactional emails (like order confirmations and shipping updates) often use dedicated IPs to maintain trust and reliability. Or, if you're a cold email marketing agency sending more than 150,000 emails per month, then dedicated IPs are something you must consider.

As Uncle Ben famously said(way too many times), 'With great power comes great responsibility.' The same wisdom applies here—except this time, you’re not slinging webs; you’re sending emails! 

With full control comes great responsibility. Managing a dedicated IP isn’t just plug-and-play; it requires care, starting with a 'warm-up' period to gradually increase your email volume and establish a stellar sender reputation.

If neglected or misused, even a dedicated IP can develop a poor reputation, so consistency and adherence to best practices are essential. If you want to learn more about things to consider before you get a dedicated IP address, check out this guide on buying a dedicated IP for email campaigns. 

Typical scenarios where dedicated IPs are preferred:

• Marketing/Lead gen agencies are sending large volumes of outreach emails.
• Enterprises need full control over email performance and deliverability.
• Companies want to protect and enhance their email-sending reputation.

Shared IP Address vs Dedicated IP Address: The Real Difference

Shared IP Address: The Community Pool

How It Works: Think of your emails swimming in the same pool as hundreds of other businesses. If everyone plays nicely, the water stays clean. If someone does something in the pool(IYKYK)... well, everyone suffers.

Shared IP Address Benefits

• Cost-effective: Included in most ESP plans (saves $300-3,600 annually)
• Instant setup: No warm-up period required
• Pre-established reputation: Benefit from collective good behavior
• Hands-off management: ESP handles all technical details

Shared IP Address Drawbacks

• Reputation vulnerability: Bad neighbors can sink your deliverability
• Limited control: Can't isolate problems to your sending practices
• Inconsistent performance: Deliverability varies based on pool quality

Dedicated IP Address: Your Private Penthouse 

How It Works: Imagine you own the entire building. Every email sent from your IP reflects only your sending behavior—good or bad.

Dedicated IP Address Benefits

• Complete reputation control: Your actions alone determine deliverability
• Enhanced monitoring: Access to provider-specific tools (Gmail Postmaster, Outlook SNDS)
• Consistent performance: Predictable results based on your sending practices
• Brand credibility: Helps build an exclusive sender identity

Dedicated IP Address Drawbacks

• Higher cost: $30-100/month, additional investment
• Warm-up required: 4-8 weeks to establish reputation
• Technical management: Requires ongoing monitoring and optimization
• Volume dependency: Needs 50K+ monthly emails to be effective

Buying a dedicated IP address without proper management is like buying a Ferrari and driving it into a wall—expensive and counterproductive.

Shared IP Address or Dedicated IP: How to Choose the Right Option

Choose Shared IP Address If:

• Email volume: Under 50,000 emails monthly
• Budget: Limited resources for email infrastructure
• Technical expertise: Prefer hands-off management
• Business stage: Testing email marketing effectiveness
• Sending pattern: Irregular or seasonal campaigns

Few Examples Where Shared IP is an Ideal Choice

• Local restaurants with 5,000 subscribers
• B2B consultants with targeted prospect lists
• Non-profits with donor communications

Choose a Dedicated IP Address If:

• Email volume: 100,000+ emails monthly consistently
• Business type: E-commerce, SaaS, or financial services
• Email criticality: Transactional emails (order confirmations, password resets)
• Reputation needs: Brand protection is paramount
• Resources available: Can invest in proper IP management

Few Examples Where a Dedicated IP is an Ideal Choice

• Marketing agencies sending 500K+ cold emails monthly
• E-commerce platforms with millions of order confirmations
• SaaS companies with critical user onboarding sequences

How Gmail, Outlook & Yahoo Treat Your IP 

Each major email provider has different algorithms for evaluating shared IP addresses vs dedicated IP addresses.

Gmail: The Domain Reputation King

Shared IP Address Treatment

Gmail can differentiate senders on a shared IP by examining DKIM domains, allowing individual reputation building even on shared infrastructure.

Dedicated IP Address Impact

Gmail prioritizes domain reputation over IP reputation, but dedicated IPs still provide better control and monitoring through Google Postmaster Tools.

Gmail's Golden Rule

Maintain spam complaint rates below 0.3% (3 complaints per 1,000 emails) regardless of IP type.

Outlook: The Balanced Judge

Shared IP Address

Reputation affects all senders in the pool, with Microsoft's filtering potentially impacting entire shared ranges.

Dedicated IP Address

Access to Smart Network Data Services(SNDS) for detailed monitoring, including subscriber complaints and spam trap data.

Outlook Advantage

Dedicated IP users get exclusive access to Microsoft's advanced deliverability insights.

Yahoo: The Strict Enforcer 

Yahoo employs the most aggressive approach to IP filtering.

Shared IP Address Risk

High chance of collective blocking if spam complaint rates exceed 0.3% for the entire pool.

Dedicated IP Address Benefit

Direct reputation control with access to Yahoo's Feedback Loop program for spam complaint monitoring.

Yahoo Reality Check

Yahoo may permanently block/blacklist entire shared IP ranges—no appeals, no second chances.

Universal Provider Requirements

All providers now require:

• Spam complaint rates below 0.3%
• Proper SPF, DKIM, and DMARC authentication
• Consistent sending patterns
• Clean email lists with low bounce rates

Industry Bombshell: Google and Yahoo announced that from February 2024, domains with spam rates of 0.3% or higher face automatic delivery problems, affecting both shared and dedicated IP users.

Transitioning Between IP Types

Moving from a Shared IP Address to a Dedicated IP Address

The Warm-Up Process (4-8 weeks):

1. Week 1-2: Send 50-100 emails daily to the most engaged subscribers
2. Week 3-4: Scale to 1,000-5,000 emails daily
3. Week 5-6: Increase to 10,000-50,000 emails daily
4. Week 7+: Deploy full sending volume

Pro Warm-Up Tips:

• Start with high-engagement campaigns (discounts, confirmations)
• Monitor bounce rates like a hawk (<2% is ideal)
• Use authentication protocols from day one
• Track reputation scores weekly

Switching from Dedicated to Shared IP Address

Consider this move when

• Email volume drops below 50K monthly
• Budget constraints require cost reduction
• Technical management becomes overwhelming

Transition Warning: You'll lose reputation control and may experience temporary fluctuations in email deliverability.

Get a Dedicated IP Address via SmartServers by Smartlead

If you’re looking to get a dedicated IP address to take full control of your email deliverability, SmartServers is the perfect add-on to consider. SmartServers enables you to get a dedicated IP address tailored to your business needs, ensuring your emails are sent from a reliable and exclusive source.

What Is SmartServers?

SmartServers is an offering from Smartlead that provides dedicated IP addresses for your email campaigns. By using SmartServers, you can separate your email reputation from others and reduce the risks of deliverability issues often associated with shared IPs.

Key Features of SmartServers

• Designed for businesses that rely on high-volume email campaigns, transactional emails, or brand-critical communications
• High email deliverability and improved reply rates with dedicated IP addresses and infrastructure
• Dedicated server management 
• Easy integration with Smartlead API
• Manage and track server performance with advanced SQL query tools that can also help you find trends in SmartServers. 

By opting for SmartServers, you get a competitive edge and can ensure that your emails reach your audience consistently and effectively. To learn more, visit here.

Conclusion

Understanding the differences between dedicated and shared IP addresses is crucial to managing your email reputation and deliverability. Both options come with their own set of benefits and challenges, and the right choice ultimately depends on factors like business size, email volume, and long-term goals.

The Bottom Line:

• Shared IP Address: Perfect for businesses under 50K emails monthly seeking cost-effective solutions
• Dedicated IP Address: Essential for 100K+ email senders requiring maximum deliverability control

Both options can achieve excellent results when appropriately managed, but your specific business needs should drive the decision. Start with a shared IP address to test your email strategy, then upgrade to a dedicated IP address as your volume and requirements grow.

Remember: Great email content + proper IP strategy + consistent sending = inbox success. 

To elevate your email deliverability to the next level, consider incorporating SmartServers into your toolkit. With this add-on, you can get a dedicated IP address and ensure reliable, consistent email performance. Take the next step with SmartServers and elevate your email strategy today!

You can start with our 14-day trial plan to test the platform and get SmartServers for your dedicated sending infrastructure.

FAQ

What is a shared IP address in email marketing?

A shared IP address is used by multiple businesses simultaneously to send emails. The ESP manages the IP's reputation based on the collective sending behavior of all users.

When should I switch to a dedicated IP address?

Switch to a dedicated IP address when you consistently send 100,000+ emails monthly, need complete reputation control, or send mission-critical transactional emails.

How much does a dedicated IP address cost?

Dedicated IP addresses typically cost an additional $30-300 per month, depending on your email service provider and plan level.

Can shared IP addresses hurt my email deliverability?

Yes, if other users on your shared IP address engage in poor sending practices, it can negatively impact your deliverability even if you follow email deliverability best practices.

How long does it take to warm up a dedicated IP address?

Dedicated IP warm-up typically takes 4-8 weeks, gradually increasing from 50 emails daily to your full sending volume.

Do I need technical expertise for dedicated IP management?

Yes, dedicated IP addresses require ongoing monitoring of reputation scores, bounce rates, spam complaints, and authentication protocols.

Which email providers prioritize IP reputation more?

Yahoo is most aggressive about IP-level filtering, Outlook maintains a balanced IP/domain focus, while Gmail prioritizes domain reputation over IP reputation.

‍